CLASS 10 CIVICS · CHAPTER 1 · STUDY NOTES
Power-sharing
Understand why sharing power can strengthen a country. Compare Belgium and Sri Lanka, distinguish the four forms of sharing and explain both practical and democratic reasons for it.
01 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Power belongs to people, not one person
Power-sharing means that different people and institutions have a real voice in decisions.
1. Power needs checks
A government makes decisions that affect everyone: school rules, roads, languages and rights. Democracy asks who can take these decisions, who can question them and whose interests must be heard.
2. People must have a voice
Giving every job to one person may look quick. But unchecked power can ignore other people. Sharing power creates participation and limits misuse.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
Power-sharing is useful in small societies too. Even people who speak one language can disagree about priorities and need protection against arbitrary decisions.
Taking turns as class monitor is a useful analogy for rotation, but it does not show all the constitutional checks, jurisdictions and group representation found in a country.
Your turn
Question
A small town has one main language. Does that make sharing power unnecessary?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 1, 6, 8 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
03 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Sri Lanka: language and identity
Sri Lanka’s different communities needed equal citizenship and recognition.
1. Read language and religion separately
Sri Lanka is an island south of India. In the chapter’s case-study figures, Sinhala speakers form 74% and Tamil speakers 18%. Sri Lankan Tamils include long-established Tamil communities, concentrated especially in the north and east. Indian Tamils have ancestry linked to plantation labour brought from India in the colonial period.
2. Understand the historical setting
Language and religion are not the same classification. People speaking the same language may follow different religions, and followers of one religion may speak different languages.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
The chapter gives 13% for Sri Lankan Tamils within the country’s population. That figure is a subset of the 18% Tamil-speaking category, not an extra group to add to it. The remaining difference is 5 percentage points in the textbook’s account.
Do not add religious percentages to language percentages. These categories can overlap. Also avoid the claim that every Sinhala speaker is Buddhist or that every Tamil speaker has the same religion.
Your turn
Question
Can a person belong to both a language community and a religious community? Why does this matter?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 2, 3 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
04 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Majoritarianism: when numbers become domination
Winning a majority does not give a community permission to ignore everyone else.
1. What the majority decided
Sri Lanka became independent in 1948. In the historical account, a 1956 law made Sinhala the sole official language. Preferential policies favoured Sinhala applicants in education and government employment, and constitutional policy gave Buddhism special protection.
2. Why exclusion caused conflict
Tamils felt excluded from equal opportunities and recognition. They sought recognition of Tamil, regional autonomy and equality in education and jobs. Repeated denial deepened mistrust; by the 1980s some organisations demanded a separate Tamil Eelam.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
The conflict became a civil war and ended in 2009. People from different communities were killed, displaced or lost livelihoods. Majority domination harmed the country as a whole, not only the minority.
Majority rule is a way to decide after fair participation, subject to rights. Majoritarianism turns a community’s numerical strength into a claim to permanent superiority. The 1956 language policy is historical; it should not be presented as the complete current law on Sri Lanka’s languages.
Your turn
Question
What is wrong with saying “we have more votes, so your language no longer matters”?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 3, 4 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
05 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Belgium: share power to stay together
Belgium’s leaders adjusted the rules so that neither main language group could simply dominate.
1. Share authority at the centre
Between 1970 and 1993, Belgium amended its Constitution four times to accommodate regional and cultural differences. Dutch- and French-speaking ministers have equal numbers in the central government. Some special laws also need a majority within each linguistic group.
2. Protect regional voices
Regional governments received powers that are not merely orders from the centre. Brussels has a separate government with equal representation of the two main communities. These arrangements require cooperation even when one group has more people.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
French speakers accepted equal representation in Brussels, where they were the larger group, because Dutch speakers accepted equality at the centre, where Dutch speakers were larger. Both sides made a concession to protect shared interests.
The model helped avoid a possible linguistic division and reduced major-community conflict. It is complex, but complexity is not the same as failure. The European Union’s major institutions in Brussels are background context, not the cause of Belgium’s power-sharing rules.
Your turn
Question
Why might the larger group accept equal representation instead of demanding every decision follow population size?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 4, 5 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
06 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
A community government follows a language group
Belgium shares power by language community as well as by territory.
1. Who chooses it?
Belgium’s community governments deal with cultural, educational and language-related matters. They are elected through the language-community arrangements described in the chapter. The idea is to give a language community a voice over these concerns, rather than relying only on a territorial government.
2. What can it decide?
Central government, regional government and community government answer different questions: country-wide matters, regional matters and community matters.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
A language community can have members living in more than one place. This is why community-based sharing differs from drawing a district boundary.
This example illustrates sharing among social groups. Regional governments illustrate sharing among levels. One country can use several forms of sharing at the same time.
Your turn
Question
Is community government just another name for State government?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 5 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
07 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Two reasons: better outcomes and equal participation
Power-sharing is useful—and it is also right in a democracy.
1. Sharing reduces conflict
The prudential reason is practical: sharing can reduce social conflict, build stability and protect unity. The moral reason is democratic: people affected by decisions have a right to be consulted and participate.
2. Participation is a right
A government gains legitimacy when citizens can influence it and feel that it is their government. Even if one person could act quickly, speed alone would not remove the right to participation.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
A local hearing on water supply can have both benefits: residents may reveal a broken pipe that officials missed, and those residents deserve a say in a decision affecting their lives.
Moral does not mean “religious” in this argument. It means the democratic value of participation. Prudential does not mean selfishness; it concerns practical effects on people and institutions.
Your turn
Question
A town consults residents because they have a right to a say. Which reason is this? How could you add a prudential reason?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 6 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
08 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Horizontal sharing: different organs, mutual checks
The legislature, executive and judiciary have different jobs at the same level of government.
1. Different organs, different jobs
The legislature makes laws, the executive implements them, and the judiciary interprets law and reviews legality. Dividing roles prevents one organ from taking all power. Checks and balances allow an organ to limit misuse by another.
2. Checks do not mean identical powers
In a parliamentary system, the executive answers to the legislature. Independent courts can review executive action and laws for constitutional validity.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
Horizontal means sharing among organs at one level. It does not mean that courts are below ministers or that judges run every government programme.
Judicial independence lets courts examine government action without simply taking orders from the executive. Independence and constitutional limits can exist together.
Your turn
Question
A court finds an executive action unconstitutional. Is this horizontal or vertical sharing? Explain.
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 8 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
09 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Vertical sharing: country, State and local level
Different levels handle different responsibilities under agreed rules.
1. More than one level
In India, power is shared among the Union government, State governments and local bodies such as panchayats and municipalities. Federal sharing means the Constitution protects the division between Union and States.
2. Constitutional protection matters
A State’s authority is not just a favour that the Union can freely take back. The detailed division is the subject of the next chapter.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
The distinction is about level, not about which political party holds office. The same party can govern at more than one level and the constitutional division still matters.
Horizontal and vertical sharing can happen together: a State itself has a legislature, executive and judiciary-related institutions while also sharing responsibilities with the Union.
Your turn
Question
If one party wins both Union and State elections, does vertical sharing disappear?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 8, 9 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
11 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Parties share office; groups influence decisions
Sharing can happen through competition, coalitions and public influence.
1. Voters can change rulers
Different parties compete for power, so it need not stay permanently with one party. If two or more parties jointly form a government, they share office in a coalition.
2. Groups can influence decisions
Pressure groups and movements—such as workers’ or farmers’ organisations—can influence public decisions through petitions, public discussion, committees and peaceful mobilisation. They need not become ministers to influence policy.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
An electoral alliance is an agreement to cooperate in elections. It becomes a governing coalition if parties actually share government responsibility. The terms are related but not identical.
Influence does not mean a group may override everyone’s rights or bypass lawful procedures. Democracies make room for interests while requiring accountable decisions.
Your turn
Question
A farmers’ association sends a petition, while two parties jointly appoint ministers. Which is the coalition?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 9, 10 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
12 / EXPLORE & UNDERSTAND
Recognise the form—and explain the purpose
Use two questions: who shares power, and why does the arrangement matter?
1. Name the arrangement
Organs sharing power means horizontal sharing; levels sharing means vertical sharing; communities gaining representation means social-group sharing; parties sharing office means coalition sharing. An example can contain more than one form.
2. Explain why it matters
Power-sharing can take time and involve disagreement. That is a reason to design workable rules, not automatically a reason to abandon participation or minority protection.
A little deeper: Understand the reason
The textbook’s Lebanon story raises a dilemma: community guarantees can help reassure groups after conflict, but rigid community labels can restrict an individual’s access to office. It is a discussion case, not proof that every country should copy that arrangement.
A good explanation can recognise both peace and inclusion concerns and the need for individual freedom. Evaluate how rules protect people, rather than assuming every form of sharing must be identical everywhere.
Your turn
Question
A State government questions the Union’s revenue-sharing rule. What form is mainly involved, and what would an explanation need?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeCHAPTER RECAP
Take these ideas with you
- Power-sharing can reduce conflict and respects people’s right to participate.
- Power may be shared among organs, levels, social groups and political organisations.
- Majority rule should not become permanent domination over a community.
Use your understanding in a new situation
Question
A court checks whether a government action follows the Constitution. Which form of sharing does this illustrate?
Sign in to see the answer
Write your own answer and compare it with ours. It’s free.
Sign inNew here? Sign up freeNCERT · Chapter source PDF, pages 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 · Original Learnijoy explanations and practice.
